My friend and colleague, Eva Valvo, said the case of the German politician, Baron Karl Theodor zu Guttenberg, who has resigned because he was accused of plagiarism in an article that I am pleased to recall here .
Eva and I apologize to my readers if I add all that on it's only as dialectic, and therefore in the shadow of others' thoughts, but I felt that the only way they could reconcile my views in an appropriate and consistent .
share everything and argues that Eve, by which they are picky, inflation: if you get to be in Italy in the section secretaries neighborhood of Lipu with a title such as a doctorate, not because doctorate, but only a lucky - and sometimes studied - coincidence, or PhD would be an alibi to justify a post office.
hand, it must be said that the doctorate, as is done in Italy, has no real reason to be a plus: I'm much more catastrophic, but I'm fine ... accept the usus dicendi of our common friend, Angela, when it repeats that the quality of the PhD is independent of the titration, or even from home, but is in very real terms (the teachers, tutors, educational system, etc..) in which it is condotto.
Un sistema così arbitrario (anche senza scendere nel dettaglio delle sue colpe reali, oggettive e strutturali) non merita obiettivamente nessuna pregiudiziale preferenza. A meno che, è ovvio, non ci sia una pesante autoreferenzialità nel rilascio dei titoli, per cui si premiano coloro a cui si sono rilasciati i titoli più alti (sempre sottoposti, per altro, al veleno dei sospetti, più o meno fondati).
D'altra parte, una società deve avere degli strumenti obiettivi per valutare carriere e valore degli aspiranti scalatori alle sfere più alte della società stessa (in questo, il criterio da macelleria delle mafie è brutale, ma efficientissimo e indiscutibile per trasparenza). The all-Italian conflict is to establish rules for the recognition and repeated disregard for depreciation of a degree in itself is very quick to vanish for a social consciousness around the concept of qualification.
Form ultraspecialisti in a society is ignorant of how to make gold taps in the wilderness, the desert dwellers deserve, like all the best fittings, but the water that you should think about before. What would be really genuinely "political" in which a "politician" should fit with its shiny doctorate?
The summative test ("I also a doctorate," as parallel with any other certificate courses of study and independent from them) in Italy takes place in a cultural journey, or even social, but if there's one thing for sure is that these two ways - cultural and social - do not go hand step and fail to define what I would call mundane preparing to do something.
Finally, congratulations to expect too much with the good Baron Karl Theodor zu Guttenberg, having no acquaintance with all the facts (let alone the hype advertising - public and private - spot), but we can not appreciate human dignity, social and even cultural such an act implies. Excessive or not, the measure gave an address and a specific example of civil society. From this point of view, chapeau, my beloved Germany!
0 comments:
Post a Comment